I agree that multiple connectors is bigger, more expensive, makes packaging difficult, etc. That's why I started this thread. I wanted to see if anybody thought that using a 15-pin instead of 2 9-pins made sense.sprocket wrote: 1. Having two connectors to support CAN is unecessary and expensive because it may force custom tooled packaging.
2. A single 9-pin dsub can be edge mounted to a pcb, taking almost no area. Other types of connectors take more board area and are a pain to work with in the field. Dsubs are used everywhere and installation tools are cheap.
3. It is not necessary to have a pass-thru design. The networking and computer world abandonded this topology decades ago in favour of star architectures because of nasty fault multiplication issues.. The AXIS-9A is the wiring hub for this.
CAN is a multi-drop protocol. These designs are not really "pass-thru." The pins on the connectors are directly connected by traces on the PCB. I did this because it's very difficult to reliably solder/crimp more than one conductor onto most D-SUB connectors. It's not impossible, but are we not catering to beginners and experimenters? Maybe I'm wrong.
Multi-drop protocols are standard in the industrial controls business. Modbus, ControlNet, DeviceNet, Remote I/O, Profibus are all multi-drop. The industrial controls world doesn't like star configurations due to the single point of failure issues. Even Ethernet (a new player in this world) is being made to look more multi-drop. I would argue that our airplanes are more similar to the industrial controls world than to the computer networking world.
Part of the reason for using CAN in the first place is to be able to integrate multiple devices throughout the airplane with a minimum of wiring. A star topology does nothing to help with this. I don't see where the 'nasty fault multiplication issues' are.
I think the idea of a CAN based trim servo controller is awesome! It was a trim controller that gave me the idea to start working on CAN-FIX to start with. I guess I don't know what the "questionable feature" is?4. I have complete a CAN design for the M-PWR-2. It alread adds substantially to the cost. Adding a second dsub 9 would require a larger package. As a result the BOM costs would double. That's a steep cost for a questionable feature.