Connector Discussion

Discussion forum for the CAN-FIX protocol. This is a CANBus based communications protocol specifically suited for experimental aviation.

Moderators: John Nicol, birkelbach

birkelbach
Posts: 193
Joined: 04 Sep 2012, 14:42

Connector Discussion

Post by birkelbach »

The current specification for CAN-FIX calls for two DB-9 connectors to be used as the network/power connections. DB-9 is a standard CAN connector so that made sense. It's also cheap and readily available. Using two (one male and one female) makes it easy to daisy chain the network. It's also good for testing and troubleshooting because nodes can easily bypassed or added.

Recently, I've been trying to come up with a way to create a standard form factor / enclosure layout. The two DB-9 connectors make finding a small enclosure fairly difficult. At least in the places that I have been looking. It seems to me that a 15 pin connector would let us get all 10 CAN-FIX signals and power, in and out with some pins left over.

Jeff suggested this connector a while back, and I like it too. http://www.mouser.com/new/connectors/molex_MX120G/ It's 12 pins so it covers the CAN-FIX data and power. It's also IP67 so it would be suitable in places where it could get wet. Another connector could be added for I/O.

So what do you guys think about specifying a DB-15 and maybe a DB-25 along with the DB-9 pair? Any other suggestions?
Phil Birkelbach
Waller, Texas
RV-7 727WB
www.myrv7.com
User avatar
jeff54il
Posts: 229
Joined: 30 Nov 2011, 12:36
Location: Holon Israel

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by jeff54il »

Hi Phil,
I don't remember suggesting the Molex MX120G connector system - but there could be 2 reasons for this: 1. Bad memory - if my head wasn't screwed onto my body I'd forget that also, or 2. Not the same Jeff.

Nevertheless I do like this connector - IP67 is good, it can take pretty hefty currents, and the connection is physically locked. I do have a non-critical problem with it - the 3.2 mm (125 mil) pitch makes it a physically large connector. A 15 pin version of it is even larger - in fact the connector is bigger than the modern Arduino (or whatever) board to which it's connected. The big pitch enables the high current capacity, but I suspect our modern applications don't need such high power/current.
To save weight and real estate I would suggest a 50 mil (or even a 25 mil) pitch.

Don't get me wrong - I don't know of an IP67 25 mil connector and I haven't researched the subject. I'm just making a nuisance of myself ;)
Bring them home NOW :cry: :shock:
birkelbach
Posts: 193
Joined: 04 Sep 2012, 14:42

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by birkelbach »

jeff54il wrote:Hi Phil,
I don't remember suggesting the Molex MX120G connector system <<SNIP>>
Opps my mistake. I did a search for it, saw your userid and got a little quick on the draw. It was actually Dave that found it, and suggested it.

It is a big connector but that might be okay when needed, for either current draw or weather proofing. The D-sub connectors can handle about 5 amps. That should be enough for every sensor on the plane, a trim motor or two and some LED position lights (maybe).
Phil Birkelbach
Waller, Texas
RV-7 727WB
www.myrv7.com
User avatar
John Nicol
Posts: 611
Joined: 23 Nov 2011, 12:17
Contact:

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by John Nicol »

I know that Vern has done a lot of research in this area and we have also discussed at length off-line. He has not found a better package than the 9, 15 and 25 pin d-subs with plastic packaging for his range of electronics. For the M-PWR trim motor controllers, he has used a hammond box, which is a good form-factor for that design. I guess we might be able to come up with 3D- printable box designs for larger electronics enclosures, but the d-sub might still be the way to go. We can also screw them down into the appropriate male or female receptacle and we can also daisy-chain them with something like the Axis connector boards to create plug-and-play daughter boards?
-----
John Nicol
Founder, MakerPlane
User avatar
jeff54il
Posts: 229
Joined: 30 Nov 2011, 12:36
Location: Holon Israel

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by jeff54il »

birkelbach wrote: Opps my mistake. I did a search for it, saw your userid and got a little quick on the draw. It was actually Dave that found it, and suggested it.<<SNIP>>
Ok - anyway I'm glad I thought of it ;)
Bring them home NOW :cry: :shock:
User avatar
jeff54il
Posts: 229
Joined: 30 Nov 2011, 12:36
Location: Holon Israel

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by jeff54il »

The Hammond boxes seem great - cast aluminum (RFI protected) and sealed to IP65 (enough for us) with a silicon gasket (option) and machine screws. The smallest one (45 mm square inside) will package a small arduino but you'll have a hard time connecting to it with a 3.2 mm pitch IP67 connector - even the 9 pin version. Another "but": ... but it weighs in at more than 60 grams - 3 to 5 times the weight of the arduino, and together with the connector it will probably total at more than 100 grams. We can live with this but the grams add up. In the R/C world 100 grams is out of the question. To me it just doesn't seem right - 10 grams of electronics wrapped in 90 grams of packaging. (BTW how much does software weigh? 8-) )
Hammond_Box_Smallest.jpg
Hammond_1590LLB.PDF
(360.71 KiB) Downloaded 851 times
3D printing has some great advantages - custom design, home built, lighter, etc. Disadvantage: Limited RFI protection (if any), although I don't know how much RFI protection we need.
My 2 cents party pooping.
Attachments
Hammond_Box_Smallest.jpg
Bring them home NOW :cry: :shock:
birkelbach
Posts: 193
Joined: 04 Sep 2012, 14:42

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by birkelbach »

This is more the speed I was thinking if we needed the RFI protection...

http://www.hammondmfg.com/dwg18_FL.htm

These would be much lighter and still have the RFI protection. No IP65 though. If we need IP65 we probably can't cut a hole in it and stick a DSub connector out of it anyway. Now the question is, do we need the RFI protection? The Arduinos and most of the CAN controllers operate at 16MHz. Those traces on the PCB's are typically very very short. The CAN Bus operates at 125kHz to 1Mhz and I generally try to keep those traces to a minimum too. Somebody smarter than me would have to chime in on the necessity of RFI protection in this environment. I don't worry too much about RFI getting in and messing things up. I'd worry more about things getting out and causing noise in the intercom or creating sensor noise.
Phil Birkelbach
Waller, Texas
RV-7 727WB
www.myrv7.com
birkelbach
Posts: 193
Joined: 04 Sep 2012, 14:42

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by birkelbach »

So here is an example that I've been working on...
CAN-Base-4.5x3.png
This is a board with an ATMega328 with CAN Bus that is supposed to fit a specific Poly-Case enclosure (datasheet attached). It has the dual connectors and I tried to cram as much of it into the corner as I could. As it is now it would do nothing except talk CAN, but about a third of the board is unpopulated for adding the rest of the 'stuff'. If that's not enough room, the headers on the side can be used to bring signals to another board that could have the rest of the circuit. It's a tad on the big side and that's why I started this thread.
CAN-Base-4.5x3.pdf
(69.95 KiB) Downloaded 861 times
PolyCase-4.5x3.pdf
(406.31 KiB) Downloaded 885 times
The one above was done with all through hole components, so it can be built by mere mortals. I did a little test yesterday to see how small I could get this same functionality using surface mount components and a microController with CAN built in. It can be done in about 2 square inches with components only on one side of the board and using a DB-15 as the connector. Here is a rough idea of what that looks like. This doesn't have reverse polarity protection and it's not "Arduino compatible" like the one above, but it's little.
Tiny.png
This is all a very preliminary work in progress, I just wanted to show you guys what I was thinking and get your comments. These were all quick hacks so I don't have a lot of emotional attachment to them. Fire away.
Phil Birkelbach
Waller, Texas
RV-7 727WB
www.myrv7.com
sprocket
Posts: 40
Joined: 28 Oct 2012, 23:09

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by sprocket »

John Nicol wrote:I know that Vern has done a lot of research in this area and we have also discussed at length off-line. He has not found a better package than the 9, 15 and 25 pin d-subs with plastic packaging for his range of electronics. For the M-PWR trim motor controllers, he has used a hammond box, which is a good form-factor for that design. I guess we might be able to come up with 3D- printable box designs for larger electronics enclosures, but the d-sub might still be the way to go. We can also screw them down into the appropriate male or female receptacle and we can also daisy-chain them with something like the Axis connector boards to create plug-and-play daughter boards?
I wish I'd been paying attention to this thread earlier. I have an opinion, as always, so here it is:

1. Having two connectors to support CAN is unecessary and expensive because it may force custom tooled packaging.
2. A single 9-pin dsub can be edge mounted to a pcb, taking almost no area. Other types of connectors take more board area and are a pain to work with in the field. Dsubs are used everywhere and installation tools are cheap.
3. It is not necessary to have a pass-thru design. The networking and computer world abandonded this topology decades ago in favour of star architectures because of nasty fault multiplication issues.. The AXIS-9A is the wiring hub for this.
4. I have complete a CAN design for the M-PWR-2. It alread adds substantially to the cost. Adding a second dsub 9 would require a larger package. As a result the BOM costs would double. That's a steep cost for a questionable feature.
5. Repeat after me... It's never about the electronics, it's always about the package. Never forget this. If you forget, slap yourself and start again.
6. Reread point 5 and look at the products i've designed.
V e r n
User avatar
jeff54il
Posts: 229
Joined: 30 Nov 2011, 12:36
Location: Holon Israel

Re: Connector Discussion

Post by jeff54il »

sprocket wrote: 5. Repeat after me... It's never about the electronics, it's always about the package. Never forget this. If you forget, slap yourself and start again.
I can't allow Vern to be one up on me so I have to make a comment on this.

I absolutely agree with the above - especially in aircraft where the environment is particularly harsh, and we have to keep the weight of the thing as one of the main design issues. It also beats me why almost all electronics packages are rectangular/prismatic while aircraft are by their nature curved/round.
Phil’s “tiny” experiment is really interesting – the striking contrast between the small PCB and the huge DB15 connector. The connector alone will probably weigh twice as much as the PCB and it has absolutely no IP protection whatsoever, not to mention RFI protection and the weight of the mating connector. So, my question: Does anybody know of a connector system similar to the dsub but using a 50-60 mil pitch? IP protection wouldn’t hurt either.
Bring them home NOW :cry: :shock:
Post Reply